We're delighted to share the results of our Twitter challenge to #DefineRhetoric. Since April, friends of Harlot have generously created, collected, and tweeted their favorite versions of the always-disputed definitions of rhetoric, that harlot of the arts. Many thanks to everyone who got involved! There were so many great contributions that we can't list them all here, but we wanted to share some of the wealth of honorable mentions as well as the winners. As you can see, the results are varied and awesome. We picked our favorites—let us know yours!
First Place — Rhetoric is a bag of Halloween candy, sometimes you get the good stuff and sometimes you get apples with razor blades. @TheOriginalRock
Second Place — “The entire range of resources that human beings share for producing effects on one another—Wayne C. Booth @cdmandrews
Third Place — "Listen to me!" says my niece while holding my face in her hands. @denisejeannee
Fourth Place — Well... that depends... who's asking? @OccupyRhetoric
Rhetoric is a selection and deflection of reality. (Inspired by Burke.) @cdmandrews
“Listen to me!” says my niece while holding my face in her hands. @denisejeannee
The Borg had it all wrong. Resistance is rhetoric. @LouFisto
Rhetoric is like the moon. It is, at present, synchronously oriented to the rotation of another body around which it orbits. @Schmeggelz
Rhetoric is discourse in lingerie. @soundb0mb3r
Rhetoric isn't what you thought it was. @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is a pun on causality. @postsilence
Rhetoric: Don’t get it wet or feed it after midnight. @LouFisto
Rhetoric = Wearing too much eyeliner after he leaves you. @donorahillard
Rhetoric is a bag of Halloween candy, sometimes you get the good stuff and sometimes you get apples with razor blades. @TheOriginalRock
The role of rhetoric is convincing people of the truth so they can dismiss their ignorance. @TheOriginalRock
#definerhetoric: utterly the bass line in Lou Reed’s “Walk On the Wild Side.” Tonight anyway @thatssomcginnis
Rhetoric is the realization you just got bamboozled, outwitted, or amazed—or all three at the same time @TheOriginalRock
“Nothing about this cigarette, packaging, or color should be interpreted to mean safer.” @donorahillard
Rhetoric is figuring out how to use Twitter without looking like a "digital immigrant." @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric depends on how close you pay attention to what was said. @TheOriginalRock
Eventually someone will come who understands @donorahillard
The role of rhetoric is convincing people of the truth so they can dismiss their ignorance. @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is what you said vs. what they heard. @TheOriginalRock
So it’s basically me screaming “Black Cream” into a little box all day long @donorahillard
Rhetoric is I know you are but what am I @OccupyRhetoric
Rhetoric: what is used when truth is on your side, against it or simply at stake @occupyrhetoric
Rhetoric is the art of spackling enthymemes @postsilence
Rhetoric is the selection and deflection of reality (inspired by burke)@cmandrews
"The entire range of resources that human beings share for producing effects on one another"- wayne c. booth @cmandrews
"Listen to me!" says my niece while holding my face in her hands. @denisejeannee
Rhetoric isn’t @dianekeeling
Rhetoric is necessarily strange. It is the sharing of unfamiliar thoughts from foreign bodies. All else is choir-preaching. @jimmy_butts
“well that depends…who’s asking?” @occupyrhetoric
Gesturing towards (or directly upon) an object so as to turn another’s gaze upon it. Like you would if you saw a(n) ____. @occupyrhetoric
Rhetoric is something that is really hard to understand when you come in with a set definition, agenda, or perspective. @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is a fancy label for the process and consequences of naming and framing reality. @anokaydane
#DefineRhetoric is an act of rhetoric itself, defined through action. Rhetoric outside of action is like Latin, dead on arrival. @plcorbett
Rhetoric can be the sun that takes away the fog, or it can be the fog... @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric asks you, "How do YOU define rheoric?" @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is the difference between preventing war and preparing for war. @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is how you scare the crap out of people to make them do certain things or vote certain ways. @TheOriginalRock
μια ικανότητα που σε κάθε περίπτωση για να δείτε τα διαθέσιμα μέσα της πειθούς #AristotlewasaThoughtNinja @anokaydane
"'rhetoric' is at once an embedded cultural practice and an inventive attitude" #DanielGross @anokaydane
Rhetoric is the thing your mother warned you about... and she was right! @TheOriginalRock
People try to control it, people try to mis-define it, people try to rewrap it, but few actually understand it. @TheOriginalRock
Rhetoric is knowing the power and the pain of words. @TheOriginalRock
Thanks for playing! Chime in below if you have additions, revisions, objections, etc. And stay tuned for next year's rematch...
Image credit: "Twitter" by eldh on Flickr by eldh on Flickr